Hemorrhagic Bowel Syndrome (HBS) in Swine
Originally published by the National Pork Board.
Reviewed July 2020
Historical reports of hemorrhagic bowel syndrome (HBS) in swine describe infrequent, explosive outbreaks of sudden deaths with intestinal hemorrhage and no apparent infectious cause. Hemorrhagic bowel syndrome does not have a single, known etiology nor are specific risk factors consistently associated with the deaths. A diagnosis of HBS is applied only after thorough efforts to rule out other causes of rapid death and intestinal hemorrhage have been completed. The most common differential diagnoses are intestinal volvulus (twisted gut), the hemorrhagic form of porcine proliferative enteritis (PPE, ileitis), gastric ulcers, bacterial toxemia (e.g. acute infections with Salmonella or hemolytic E. coli), or other causes of sudden death. Control requires that one accurately rule out other known causes of sudden death, objectively assess environment and feeding practices, and properly manage risk factors that may be present. Reports of specific, consistently successful therapeutic interventions are rare.
- Review hemorrhagic bowel syndrome (HBS)
- Outline a procedure for diagnosis of HBS
- Present known risk factors and management practices for control of HBS
Review and History
Sporadic cases of sudden intestinal hemorrhagic syndromes have been reported since the 1950’s. Careful interpretation of historical reports is warranted since ulceration of the pars esophagea (gastric ulcers) and hemorrhagic forms of proliferative enteritis (ileitis) are not excluded in some discussions. In 1964, Kinnaird1 described HBS’s appearance grossly and microscopically as a result of capillary “oozing” with no cause demonstrated. He suggested increased incidence with feeding of pelleted rations, with feeding liquid whey, or with high supplemental copper in diets.
In 1967, Jones2 also described the lesions of an intestinal hemorrhagic syndrome associated with the feeding of liquid whey. Mortality was increased when feeding fresh whey compared to stored whey. Attempts to demonstrate an immune-mediated mechanism failed. Bacteriology grew E. coli and Clostridium perfringens type A from intestine. Attempts to reproduce disease by administering filtered intestinal contents intravenously or orally failed. Others in brief reports were unable to reproduce disease by oral inoculation of E. coli and Clostridium perfringens type A isolated from affected swine. Most of the authors of these early case reports and studies did not find evidence for, nor did they suggest an infectious cause.
In 1970, O’Neill3 proposed an allergic mechanism for an explosive outbreak in several sites in a single system, but in this case not all pigs died and diarrhea was a feature. In 1972, Rountree suspected infectious causation, but this outbreak in retrospect, was probably PPE. In 1989, Ligget described an outbreak of hemorrhagic enteropathy that also had lesions typical for clotting dysfunction and was responsive to supplemental vitamin K.
A recognizable twist of the intestine (volvulus) is a variable finding in some studies.4,5 In a Swiss report of 436 cases of HBS, intestinal volvulus was confirmed in 56% of cases examined in the first 8 years of the study; however, by more careful examination in the next 2 years it was found in 80% of cases.6 Recent reports implicate partial or complete volvulus as a common cause of death with pathological features typical of those described for HBS.7.8 Demonstration of a partial volvulus can be quite daunting in some cases, but it is increasingly recognized in sudden death of individual animals.
Since known causes of similar presentation exist, some speculate that a diagnosis of HBS is actually a failure to accurately rule out other causes of sudden death with intestinal hemorrhage. Acute PPE and gastric ulcers can be overlooked. In some situations, necropsy of a dead pig if not high priority, is delegated to untrained personnel or simply may not be completely investigated. Some veterinarians suspect Clostridium sp. involvement similar to the jejunal hemorrhagic syndrome described in bovine, possibly associated with toxins exacerbated by Clostridium perfringens type A. However, demonstrating the presence of bacteria that are normal flora in cases with intestinal hemorrhage does not confirm causation. Clostridia are capable of producing a variety of toxins and clostridial “blooms” probably can occur after engorgement. Antimicrobials are variably effective, decreasing incidence of HBS in some herds and clostridia are not always demonstrable or isolated. Genetic tools are in place to further characterize what role, if any, certain clostridia may have in HBS. Similarly, E. coli or other bacterial “blooms” where toxins have localized effects can create shock-like conditions in the intestine. Others postulate direct irritation or hypersensitivity to some feed ingredient, additive, or metabolite. Immune-mediated hypersensitivity has been considered, but is very hard to prove. The infrequent cases of high mortality (deaths) associated with feeding whey may be in these latter categories.
Clearly, the current view of HBS includes several different clinical and pathological causes. Early reports described HBS as infrequent outbreaks of relatively high (up to 20%) mortality. In contrast, HBS is currently perceived as a common cause of mortality in herds in the US. Production systems attribute mortality rates of 0.1-7% to HBS in the grow-finish phase. Lower mortality and widespread occurrence, with lack of major feed changes suggest factors other than those implicated in early reports. Demonstration of a partial volvulus can be difficult and is likely to be inaccurately diagnosed as HBS in many cases. Hemorrhagic bowel syndrome should not be viewed as a single disease with a single cause.
Common clinical presentation of HBS is finding a previously healthy pig dead between two and eight months of age; most are rapidly growing pigs between four and six months of age (150 and 270 lb.). The remainder of the group is asymptomatic. Perceptions and production records support a higher incidence of HBS in the summer months. Mortality rates are unpredictable with considerable variation between groups, ranging from 0-7%. On rare occasion, one may have the opportunity to observe clinical signs attributable to HBS. Affected pigs are reluctant to move, may vocalize because of abdominal pain and stand with their legs apart. Vocalization incites aggression by other pigs in the pen. Open mouth breathing and generalized redness is followed by lying, paleness and death. Affected pigs are not observed to have diarrhea prior to death. Similar clinical signs are observed with intestinal volvulus.
Careful necropsy is required to rule out other causes of death before rendering a diagnosis of HBS. The first priority is to rule out intestinal accident such as a volvulus. This is defined as a mechanical interruption of blood perfusion or drainage that may be partial or complete. Intestines that have compete obstruction of blood flow are black and necrotic. Those with blood flow to the intestine, but partial obstruction of blood drainage appear reddened with unclotted, bloody fluid in the lumen. With intestinal accident, there may be a portion of the intestine twisted, the entire intestine may be involved and frequently may include the cecum and colon. With the pig lying on its back, the abdominal wall is opened carefully to not disturb the position of intestinal tract. The normal position of the colon and cecum is on the left side with the blind end of the cecum pointing down. The cecum and colon may be rotated to the right when there is partial or complete volvulus of the small and/or large intestine. Examination of the root of the mesentery (connective tissue) of the small intestine may demonstrate a partial or complete twist or rather abrupt transition in perfusion, noted by a color change. The mesentery may be edematous and congested (swollen with fluid). In some cases of volvulus, there is a clear transition of normal to affected intestine between the duodenum and jejunum.
With HBS, intestinal loops are dilated with gas, limp and contain unclotted blood or dark bloody fluid. The intestinal wall may be completely congested, but not as severe as with intestinal volvulus. The cecum occasionally contains bloody fluid as well, but normal feces are usually present in the large intestine. Unfortunately, these changes are not specific for HBS and can also be observed with volvulus. The stomachs of pigs with volvulus have normal to large quantities of feed in the stomach. Stomachs contain variable quantities of feed or water with HBS, but can also be empty, similar to many other common causes of death.
Rule Out Gastric Ulcer and Ileitis
Two other conditions commonly misdiagnosed as HBS are gastric ulcers and acute hemorrhagic PPE (ileitis). One must completely examine the entrance of the esophagus into the stomach (pars esophagea) before ruling out a gastric ulcer, particularly when the intestine or colon contains dark or black blood. Acute deaths from a gastric ulcer usually have a pale carcass without bloating. Blood and blood clots may be present in the stomach, but the hallmark lesion is ulceration where the esophagus enters the stomach. The stomach usually does not contain feed. Although blood clots can be found in stomachs with acute hemorrhage from gastric ulcers, the blood that passes into the small intestine is usually unclotted and dark to black by the time it reaches the large intestine. The wall of the small intestine and colon is usually normal, although the mucosa is reddened.
The acute hemorrhagic form of PPE may have areas of intestine that are thickened, perhaps with necrosis. In some cases the intestine is limp and dilated. The wall of the intestine is not as severely or diffusely congested as with HBS or volvulus. The blood within the lumen appears fresh and often forms a rope-like clot, in contrast to unclotted, dark bloody contents of HBS or volvulus. Diarrhea may precede death, and the stomach contains scant ingesta with PPE. Further testing at a veterinary diagnostic laboratory is required to confirm PPE and differentiate HBS or volvulus in sudden cases.
Role of Intestinal Accidents
History describes HBS as infrequent outbreaks of relatively high (up to 20%) mortality. In contrast, HBS as currently perceived is a common, up to 7%, cause of mortality in US herds. There may be other factors to consider given its low mortality, widespread occurrence and lack of association with major changes in feeding practices. Recent work strongly implicates intestinal accident (twisted intestine, volvulus, torsion) as a major contributor to grow-finish mortality that may be wrongly referred to as hemorrhagic bowel syndrome. Straw conducted several prospective studies, carefully examining sudden deaths and risk factors.7,8 In one conducted at a test station with individual daily feed consumption records, six of six pigs with features of HBS were confirmed as intestinal volvulus. Moreover, five of the six had disruption of feeding behavior (disruption of feeding schedule by handling, weighing, sorting or a feeder not working) within one or two days prior to death. In this author’s experience in test facilities, it is not unusual to find occasional pigs dead the day following a disruptive event, consistent with observations of Straw. In another investigation of commercial grow-finish mortality, Straw found relatively higher incidence of sudden deaths with summer placement, pigs approaching finishing weight, and pigs fed no antibiotics; but found no relationship to other concurrent causes of mortality, to gender, or to pen density.7.8
Mechanisms proposed for volvulus help to explain relatively high prevalence across herds and low incidence within herds. Pigs usually eat several (7-13) discrete meals during daylight hours with relatively long inter-meal intervals. It is speculated that pigs consume larger, fewer meals as they get older and are predisposed to volvulus by a combination of mechanical and physiologic mechanisms. Larger meals, worsened by feeding disruptions, may alter gut motility to increase the likelihood of volvulus. Altered feeding behavior disrupts the pattern of neurologic control of intestinal movement. Body type conformation of longer and deeper carcasses may also contribute, along with pure mechanical effects of “pig play”. It is likely that many cases of (partial) volvulus are wrongly diagnosed as HBS in modern production systems.
Laboratory Assistance and Other Differentials
Autolysis (self-digestion) occurs rapidly in cases of HBS. Necropsy should be performed as quickly as possible and tissues immediately preserved in formalin and on ice. Microscopic examination of intestinal sections reveals profound diffuse congestion, affecting all aspects of the intestine. Antemortem necrosis and inflammation are not usually features, but there may be mild necrosis or cell infiltration. Thickening is not present and PPE (ileitis) is not detected. Distinct populations of bacteria are not consistently found with HBS. Microscopic lesions are similar, but not specific to volvulus or HBS.
Bacterial culture generally reveals E. coli or Clostridium perfringens from the intestine of dead pigs, including those with HBS. Most authors have not associated infectious causation with HBS, yet it is believed by some that antimicrobial treatment often changes the frequency of disease. It is important to rule out infectious causes of blood in the intestine that may threaten health of the entire group. These diseases include: PPE (ileitis caused by Lawsonia intracellularis); salmonellosis; coccidiosis; whipworms; swine dysentery (caused by Brachyspira hyodysenteriae); toxin producing E. coli; and systemic bacterial diseases (Erysipelas, Actinobacillus, etc). Clostridium perfringens type C causes hemorrhagic necrosis, but is limited to suckling pigs and not a true differential for HBS.
Differentiating post mortem autolysis, intestinal congestion and circumstances of death requires experience and knowledge. Autolysis and intestinal congestion may yield blood-tinged intestinal contents and can be present with many other sudden deaths, including trauma from fighting, porcine stress syndrome, bacterial septicemia and meningitis, or bacterial enteritis.
Other Diagnostic Considerations
Hypersensitivities are occasionally implicated in cases of explosive outbreaks of sudden deaths and diarrhea in a group of pigs, but is usually related to an abrupt change in feed or the administration of a particular drug or antibiotic. One might speculate allergy, hypersensitivity, or direct irritation of intestinal tract by the agent or its metabolites. Diarrhea is a feature in some of the pigs in this situation and not all affected pigs are found dead with the lesions typical for HBS. The original descriptions of HBS were associated with feeding whey and, indeed, still occur. Scrutiny of the history often reveals a change in whey processing, dehydration or storage. Feeding whey is considered a major risk factor for increased incidence of true HBS cases. Several authors have investigated HBS associated with whey feeding, but the mechanism remains unknown.
A final diagnosis of HBS is made only after ruling out other causes of death. Since HBS cannot be experimentally reproduced, it is best viewed as a default diagnosis due to its unknown cause and often confusing literature. Meanwhile, it is useful to consider other causes by carefully examining the carcasses and environment, along with sample submission for laboratory testing. The list of common rule-outs is long, including: autolysis, infectious agents or sudden death, and non-infectious conditions such as volvulus and gastric ulcers. Other, less likely non-infectious causes of sudden death that may cause intestinal congestion and/or blood in the intestine include:
- Anticoagulant toxicity or vitamin K deficiency
- Nasopharyngeal hemorrhage, tumor, abscess and/or erosion
- Ulceration of the glandular stomach from parasites, mycotic infection and/or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)
- Inguinal or umbilical hernia with incarceration of intestines
- Abnormal mesenteric bone formation leading to strangulation of intestine
- Acute vitamin D toxicity
- Mycotoxins are an unlikely cause and are poorly documented
- Rectal trauma usually does not cause sudden death
Risk Factors and Control
The risk factors most frequently mentioned involve disruptions of feed intake, issues with feed or water quality, or change in social status. Factors contributing to inconsistent feed consumption include: feed system failure, out of feed events, limited access to feed, limited access to water, all worsened in hot summer months. Changes in the pig’s environment or social status might include: moving a group or changing pen location, social stress of domination and competition, sorting or topping off pens at market, mixing pigs in the same pen, or perhaps when a pig jumps a pen. Speculated feed and water components that may affect intestinal flora or physiology include: high iron in water, high copper in rations, high (rancid) fat content, poor water quality, poor protein quality, abrupt changes in feed ingredients or ratios, mixing errors (mineral, salt, protein, etc), pelleted rations and high protein rations amongst others.
There is little opportunity for therapeutic intervention for individual pigs with HBS because of the rapid death that follows. Outbreaks of classic HBS respond to removal of the suspected offending feedstuff. In current production systems, HBS must be carefully differentiated from intestinal accident or other causes of death. Since incidence is usually low, intervention with management and husbandry is attempted first. A cost-benefit analysis is warranted in most herds before aggressive intervention is pursued. Empirical methods of control have included the use of feed-grade antimicrobials. Evaluation of antimicrobial efficacy is difficult since in most herds, HBS tends to be transient and seasonal. Management changes to address the perceived risk factors is usually not expensive and often is beneficial. Incidence may be reduced by simply assuring a consistent, plentiful, accessible source of palatable feed and water, avoiding mixing of pigs, and providing additional floor space.
Historical reports of hemorrhagic bowel syndrome (HBS) in swine describe infrequent, explosive outbreaks of sudden deaths with intestinal hemorrhage and no apparent infectious cause. HBS has since become a default diagnosis applied to previously healthy grow-finish swine found dead with bloated abdomen, paleness, bloody and thin-walled small intestines at necropsy, along with death attributable to no other known cause. It is an economic concern since such deaths are common across production systems, occur in healthy pigs late in the grow-finish phase and involve intervention expenses. Clinical signs are rarely observed since death occurs rapidly. Diarrhea is not a feature of this condition.
HBS as currently defined does not have a single, known etiology nor specific risk factors that are consistently associated with death. A diagnosis of HBS should be applied only after thorough efforts to rule out other causes of rapid death and intestinal hemorrhage are completed. The most common differential diagnoses are intestinal volvulus (twisted gut), the hemorrhagic form of porcine proliferative enteritis (PPE, ileitis), gastric ulcers, bacterial toxemia (e.g. acute infections with Salmonella or hemolytic E. coli), etc. Control requires that one accurately rules out other known causes of sudden death by objectively assessing the environment and feeding practices, along with managing risk factors that may be present. Reports of specific, consistently successful therapeutic interventions are rare.
References and Citations
- Kinnaird, PJ. Victoria Veterinary Proceedings, p. 45 1964.
- Jones, JET. Brit. Vet. J. 1967;123:286.
- O’Neill, P. Vet Rec 1970;87:742-747.
- Smith, WJ, Shanks, PL. Vet Rec 1971;89:55-56.
- Rowland, AC, Lawson, GHK. Vet Rec 1973;93:402.
- Häni, H, Zimmermann, W, Huber, A, Schmidt, J. Aspekte. Schweiz Arch Tierheilk 1993;135:117-124.
- Straw, B. Proceedings of American Association of Swine Veterinarians, Kansas City. pp. 401-404, 2002.
- Straw, B. Proceedings of Centralia Swine Conference, London, Ontario. 2004.
Glock, RD. Comp Cont Educ Pract Vet 1981;3(3): 5120-5131.
Ligget, AD. Comp Cont Educ 1989;11(11)1409-1413.
Ruckebusch, Y, Bueno, L. Br J Nutr 1976;35:397-405.
Schultz, RA, Daniels, GN. Proceedings of International Pig Veterinary Society, Ghent. P 363. 1984.
Schultz, RA, Daniels, GN. Vet Med February, 1984.
Schwartz, KJ. Proceedings of American Association of Swine Veterinarians, Kansas City. pp. 405-408. 2002.